Skip to content

Medical emergency? What to do

Antidepressant efficacy may be overblown

3-RXPublished July 20, 20052 min read

Key points

  • Antidepressants, for the most part, do not provide meaningful benefit, two investigators in the UK argue in a report in the British Medical Journal this week, having reviewed published medical evidence on antidepressant efficacy.
  • Joanna Moncrieff, an author of the report, said, "I do not think there is such a thing as a drug that will specifically relieve depression.
  • In fact, she continued, "I am skeptical as to whether there is a biochemical syndrome of depression despite the portrayal by the drug companies and some psychiatric literature."
  • Darrel Regier, director of the Division of Research at the American Psychiatric Association, told Reuters Health that Moncrieff and Kirsch have "written an article that selectively pulls out negative studies and conveniently ignores or mischaracterizes positive studies."

Antidepressants, for the most part, do not provide meaningful benefit, two investigators in the UK argue in a report in the British Medical Journal this week, having reviewed published medical evidence on antidepressant efficacy.

Most people with depression are often initially prescribed an antidepressant by their doctor. Prescriptions for these medications have risen dramatically in the last decade.

In an interview with Reuters Health, Dr. Joanna Moncrieff, an author of the report, said, "I do not think there is such a thing as a drug that will specifically relieve depression.

I think so-called antidepressants are just drugs that do other things, such as sedating or stimulating people."

In fact, she continued, "I am skeptical as to whether there is a biochemical syndrome of depression despite the portrayal by the drug companies and some psychiatric literature."

Moncrieff, a lecturer at the University College London and co-chair of the Critical Psychiatry Network, describes depression as a condition that "should be dealt with without drugs, because it's something people need to learn to deal with themselves." Dr. Irving Kirsch of the University of Plymouth is a co-author of the report.

In response, Dr. Darrel Regier, director of the Division of Research at the American Psychiatric Association, told Reuters Health that Moncrieff and Kirsch have "written an article that selectively pulls out negative studies and conveniently ignores or mischaracterizes positive studies."

"The interesting issue," he said, "is that it is now medical malpractice not to treat very serious major depression with medication. If in fact there were nonsignificant differences (between antidepressants and placebo), that would not be the standard of care."

"Theirs is a radical sociological approach that will do anything to deny the existence of a medical disorder that affects the brain, that somehow the brain is sacrosanct and you can't have illness of the brain," he concluded. "It really is a remarkably biased presentation."

SOURCE: British Medical Journal July 16, 2005.

The content on this site is for information only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Drug information pages are an archive and may be out of date: always follow your prescriber, your pharmacist and the current product label. In an emergency, call 911.

Filed underDepression

When to get help

Reading is for later. These need care now.

Call 911 or go to an emergency department if you or someone with you has any of these:

  • Chest pain or pressureEspecially with breathlessness, sweating or pain in the arm, jaw or back. It can be a heart attack.
  • Face drooping, arm weakness, slurred speechSigns of a stroke. Note the time they started: treatment works best within hours.
  • Severe trouble breathingIncluding a severe allergic reaction with swelling of the lips, tongue or throat.
  • Thoughts of suicideCall or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, US) any time, day or night.

Outside the US, call your local emergency number.

See a doctor within days

  1. 01A new lump, or a sore that does not healMost lumps are harmless, but anything that grows or lasts more than a few weeks should be checked.
  2. 02Unexplained weight loss or lasting fatigueLosing weight without trying, or tiredness that does not lift, can have many causes worth finding.
  3. 03A new medicine and new symptomsSide effects and interactions are common. Ask your pharmacist or prescriber before you stop anything.

General guidance only. If you are unsure how urgent a symptom is, call your doctor or a nurse advice line.