Skip to content

Medical emergency? What to do

Patients With Herniated Disk Improved With or Without Surgery

3-RXPublished November 23, 20065 min read

Key points

  • Patients with lumbar disk herniation who had surgery or nonoperative treatments showed similar levels of improvement in the reduction of pain over a 2-year period, according to a randomized trial in the November 22/29 issue of JAMA.
  • However, lumbar disk herniation (protrusion from its normal position) is often seen on imaging studies in the absence of symptoms and can regress over time without surgery, according to background information in the article.
  • The researchers found that adherence to assigned treatment was limited: 50 percent of patients assigned to surgery received surgery within 3 months of enrollment, while 30 percent of those assigned to nonoperative treatment received surgery in the same period.
  • Editor's Note: Please see the article for additional information, including other authors, author contributions and affiliations, financial disclosures, funding and support, etc.

Patients with lumbar disk herniation who had surgery or nonoperative treatments showed similar levels of improvement in the reduction of pain over a 2-year period, according to a randomized trial in the November 22/29 issue of JAMA. In all cases patients who had surgery did slightly better.

Lumbar diskectomy (surgical removal, in part or whole, of an intervertebral disk) is the most common surgical procedure performed in the United States for patients having back and leg pain. The vast majority of the procedures are elective.

However, lumbar disk herniation (protrusion from its normal position) is often seen on imaging studies in the absence of symptoms and can regress over time without surgery, according to background information in the article. High variation in regional diskectomy rates in the U.S. and lower rates internationally raise questions regarding the appropriateness and effectiveness of some of these surgeries, compared to nonoperative care, with evidence inconclusive on the optimal treatment.

James N. Weinstein, D.O., M.Sc., of Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, N.H., and colleagues compared the outcomes of surgical and nonoperative treatment for lumbar intervertebral disk herniation in the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial (SPORT), which included both a randomized trial study group and an observational study group who declined to be randomized in favor of designating their own treatment.

The randomized clinical trial enrolled patients between March 2000 and November 2004 from 13 multidisciplinary spine clinics in 11 U.S. states. The participants included 472 patients (average age, 42 years; 42 percent women) who were candidates for surgery, with imaging-confirmed lumbar intervertebral disk herniation and persistent signs and symptoms of radiculopathy (involvement of the spinal nerve roots characterized by pain that radiates from the spine, such as down the leg) for at least 6 weeks. Patients were randomized to undergo diskectomy (n = 232) vs. nonoperative treatment (n = 240), which included physical therapy, education/counseling with home exercise instruction, and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, if tolerated. There was follow-up at 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, and 1 and 2 years.

The researchers found that adherence to assigned treatment was limited: 50 percent of patients assigned to surgery received surgery within 3 months of enrollment, while 30 percent of those assigned to nonoperative treatment received surgery in the same period. Intent-to-treat analyses (in which group outcomes were assessed based on the therapy to which the patient was initially assigned) demonstrated substantial improvements for all primary (pain and physical function measures) and secondary outcomes (sciatica severity, satisfaction with symptoms, self-reported improvement, and employment status) in both treatment groups. The intent-to-treat analysis likely underrepresents the true treatment effect, while the as-treated analysis likely overestimates the true treatment effect.

"Patients in both the surgery and nonoperative treatment groups improved substantially over the first 2 years," the authors write. "Between-group differences in improvements were consistently in favor of surgery for all outcomes and at all time periods but were small and not statistically significant except for the secondary measures of sciatica severity and self-rated improvement. Because of the high numbers of patients who crossed over in both directions, conclusions about the superiority or equivalence of the treatments are not warranted based on the intent-to-treat analysis alone."

(JAMA. 2006;296:2441-2450. Available pre-embargo to the media at http://www.jamamedia.org.)

Editor's Note: Please see the article for additional information, including other authors, author contributions and affiliations, financial disclosures, funding and support, etc.

Observational Study Demonstrates that Patients Who Chose Surgery Had Greater Improvement

In the companion article, which was the observational study of SPORT, patients with persistent sciatica who had diskectomy or usual care reported improvement over 2 years, although patients who chose surgery experienced greater improvement.

The observational study group, treated at 13 spine clinics in 11 U.S. states between March 2000 and March 2003, included patients who met SPORT eligibility criteria but declined randomization. Of the 743 patients enrolled in the observational cohort, 528 patients received surgery and 191 received usual nonoperative care.

At 3 months, patients who chose surgery had greater improvement in the primary outcome measures of bodily pain, physical function, and on a disability index. These differences narrowed somewhat at 2 years.

"In this nonrandomized evaluation of patients with persistent sciatica from lumbar disk herniation who had operative or usual care, both treatment groups improved considerably over 2 years. Nonrandomized comparisons of self-reported outcomes are subject to potential confounding and must be interpreted cautiously. Nevertheless, patients who underwent diskectomy had significantly better self-reported outcomes than those who had usual care," the authors conclude.

The content on this site is for information only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Drug information pages are an archive and may be out of date: always follow your prescriber, your pharmacist and the current product label. In an emergency, call 911.

Filed underBackacheSurgery

Keep reading

Surgery

Complex spinal surgery jumps in U.S. elderly: study

Older patients with lower back pain are increasingly getting more complex and costlier spinal fusion surgeries, resulting in higher rates of life-threatening complications and increasing costs for the healthcare…

3 min read

When to get help

Reading is for later. These need care now.

Call 911 or go to an emergency department if you or someone with you has any of these:

  • Chest pain or pressureEspecially with breathlessness, sweating or pain in the arm, jaw or back. It can be a heart attack.
  • Face drooping, arm weakness, slurred speechSigns of a stroke. Note the time they started: treatment works best within hours.
  • Severe trouble breathingIncluding a severe allergic reaction with swelling of the lips, tongue or throat.
  • Thoughts of suicideCall or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, US) any time, day or night.

Outside the US, call your local emergency number.

See a doctor within days

  1. 01A new lump, or a sore that does not healMost lumps are harmless, but anything that grows or lasts more than a few weeks should be checked.
  2. 02Unexplained weight loss or lasting fatigueLosing weight without trying, or tiredness that does not lift, can have many causes worth finding.
  3. 03A new medicine and new symptomsSide effects and interactions are common. Ask your pharmacist or prescriber before you stop anything.

General guidance only. If you are unsure how urgent a symptom is, call your doctor or a nurse advice line.